Skip to content
cardrip

How to sell a card you pulled

Six routes for one slab: two keep it in the vault, four need a parcel first. What each leaves at $50, $500, and $5,000, from fee pages read on 7 October 2026.

Plan my sale

By Alexander Korsager · Checked 7 October 2026 · We earn nothing from any app on this site

PULLED
valued at$500
Pulled on Arena Club
  1. Sell-back● Stays in the vault$450
  2. In-app listing● Stays in the vault$450
  3. Whatnot▲ Ship out first≤ $440.20
  4. PSA, on eBay▲ Ship out, post in≤ $435
  5. eBay▲ Ship out first≤ $428.35
  6. Fanatics auction▲ Ship out, post in≤ $428.33
≤ means the app's shipping charge is not published and still has to come off.

Six routes, and what each needs first

Swipe through them in order: where the card has to be, the steps, the fee and the catch.

  • 1Sell it back to the app

    ● Stays in the vault
    1. 1Open the card in your collection
    2. 2Read the offer the app shows
    3. 3Accept before the app's clock runs out
    Pays
    84% to 100% of the app's value
    A $500 card leaves, on Arena Club
    $450
    10 of 27 apps put no rate in writing, and some pay in site credit.

  • 2List it inside the app

    ● Stays in the vault
    1. 1Set your own price
    2. 2Wait for another user to buy
    3. 3The app's fee comes off the sale
    Fee
    8 of 27 apps publish a fee
    A $500 card leaves, on Arena Club
    $450
    It needs a buyer inside that one app. Our dataset holds no figure for how long a listing takes to sell.

  • 3Sell it on eBay

    ▲ Ship out first
    1. 1Ask the app to post the card to you
    2. 2List it once it arrives
    3. 3Post it to the buyer
    Fee
    13.25% up to $7,500, 2.35% above, plus $0.30 or $0.40 an order
    A $500 card leaves, card in hand, after $5 postage
    $428.35
    Only 3 of 27 apps publish their shipping charge as one figure. It comes off first.

  • 4Sell it on Whatnot

    ▲ Ship out first
    1. 1Ask the app to post the card to you
    2. 2List it once it arrives
    3. 3Post it to the buyer
    Fee
    8% of the price up to $1,500, plus 2.9% and $0.30 processing
    A $500 card leaves, card in hand, after $5 postage
    $440.20
    No commission above $1,500 is a promotion Whatnot says it can end at any time. It covers card singles, not breaks.

  • 5Have PSA sell it on eBay

    ▲ Card must be in PSA Vault
    1. 1Get the slab into your PSA Vault account
    2. 2Ask PSA to list it on eBay
    3. 3PSA takes one fee; the buyer pays shipping
    Fee
    12% at $500; 13% plus $3 under $100; 7% from $5,000
    A $500 card leaves, card in hand, after $5 postage
    $435
    Rates read in the Internet Archive's copy of 31 July 2026. PSA says its vault takes PSA, SGC, BGS or CGC slabs, and states no intake fee.

  • 6Consign it to a weekly auction

    ▲ Card must be at Fanatics Collect
    1. 1Post the slab in with a submission form
    2. 2Wait 17 to 22 business days for intake
    3. 3It runs in a 10-day auction from a $5 bid
    Fee
    No seller fee; buyer pays 20% on top
    A $500 card leaves, after $5 postage, if the winner pays $500 all in
    $428.33
    A bidder who budgets for the 20% premium bids less. Its list of slabs it takes names PSA, SGC, BGS and CGC, and not TAG.
apps publish a sell-back rate17 of 27
publish an in-app listing fee8 of 27
say they ship cards out27 of 27
publish the shipping fee as one figure3 of 27

Both consigners list the graders whose slabs they take. Which grader's slabs each app packs is in the grading guide.

Your card, at $50, $500 and $5,000

It opens on Arena Club, the app with the most exit terms in writing. Pick where your card is and how close to the app's value you expect a buyer to pay.

A buyer pays, against the app's value
What each route leaves at three card values, for a card in Arena Club's vault
Route$50$500$5,000
Sell-back● Stays in the vault$45$450$4,500
In-app listing● Stays in the vault$45$450$4,500
eBay▲ Ship out first≤ $37.97≤ $428≤ $4,332
Whatnot▲ Ship out first≤ $39.25≤ $440≤ $4,730
PSA, on eBay▲ Ship out, post in≤ $35.50≤ $435≤ $4,645
Fanatics auction▲ Ship out, post in≤ $36.67≤ $428≤ $4,412
  • Green is the most that is certain on published figures. “≤” is a ceiling: a further cost on that route is not published, or depends on timing.
  • Arena Club: sell-back 90% of its value, offer open for 24 hours; shipping fee: $1 a card, plus shipping and insurance that vary by package.
  • eBay, Whatnot: before the app's shipping charge, which it does not publish as one figure.
  • PSA, on eBay: before the app's shipping charge and any PSA Vault intake fee, neither published.
  • Fanatics auction: if the winner pays the sale price all in, and before the app's shipping charge.

Every parcel route takes $5 postage and no sales tax. Whatnot's figure at $5,000 rests on a promotion it can end. For one card at any value, with your own postage and tax, use the selling fee comparer.

What a parcel route keeps, by card value

A card already in your hands, sold at its value. The shaded band is where sell-back rates in writing sit: 84% to 100%.

$50 cardshare kept

eBay75.9%
Whatnot78.5%
PSA, on eBay≤ 71.0%
Fanatics auction73.3%

$500 cardshare kept

eBay85.7%
Whatnot88.0%
PSA, on eBay≤ 87.0%
Fanatics auction85.7%

$5,000 cardshare kept

eBay86.6%
Whatnot94.6%
PSA, on eBay≤ 92.9%
Fanatics auction88.2%

At $50 no parcel route reaches the band: postage and fixed fees take too much. At $500 and $5,000 all four sit inside it, none at the top. Whether your app's offer is fair for the card is a separate question for the offer checker.

No seller fee is not no cost

Fanatics Collect's Weekly Auction takes nothing from the seller of a graded card. The buyer pays 20% on top of the bid instead.

Winner pays, all in$500
Buyer's premium, 20% of the bid− $83.33
Winning bid (hammer price)$416.67
Seller bonus for that band$16.67
Paid to you$433.33
“A 20% buyer's premium is added to the hammer price of all sales.” Fanatics Collect help centre, page dated 17 August 2026, read 7 October 2026.
Fanatics Collect auction seller bonus by hammer price, and what the seller is paid if the winner pays the top of each band all in
Winning bidSeller bonusYou keep, of what the buyer pays
$5 to $49None83.3%
$50 to $99+2%85.0%
$100 to $999+4%86.7%
$1,000 to $4,999+6%88.3%
$5,000 to $9,999+8%90.0%
$10,000 to $249,999+10%91.7%

The last column is our sum: bid plus bonus, over bid plus premium. The chart also says Fanatics Collect takes at least $3 from each Weekly Auction sale. Eligible US sellers paid in FanCash get all of what the buyer pays, but FanCash cannot be withdrawn to a bank.

How long the slow route takes

The same auction on a calendar, from Fanatics Collect's own stated timeframes. On them, a full 10-day auction closes 33 days or more after your parcel is delivered.

  1. 1. Intake17–22business daysfrom delivery until the card shows in your vault
  2. 2. Auction10daysThursday evening to the second Sunday; Flash adds a vaulted card to one already running
  3. 3. Buyer pays5 or 10daysafter the invoice: 5 on its selling page, up to 10 on its timeframes page
  4. 4. Payout1–3business daysafter the payment is processed

Against that, the shortest sell-back clock an app publishes is 15 minutes. A card you ship out is no longer in the app to sell back, so check the clock in vault or ship before you choose a slow route. Posting one card out of PSA's vault costs $7.98 or more: see PSA Vault fees.

What this page could not confirm

Each gap is left as a gap. None is filled with a guess.

Other consigners

Not readGoldin, COMC, and Probstein could not be read on 7 October 2026, so none is priced here.

Insured postage

Your figureEvery sum uses $5 postage. Insuring a $5,000 parcel costs more, and no fee page prices it.

PSA Vault intake

Not statedPSA's page gives no fee for sending a slab in, so that route is drawn as a ceiling unless the card is already there.

The winning bid

Not knowableThat an auction winner pays the card's value all in is this page's assumption. A bid can land above or below it.

Questions people ask

Do I have to ship a card out of the app to sell it?

Not for the sell-back or an in-app listing: the card stays in the vault. eBay and Whatnot need it in your hands first, and a consigner needs it in theirs. 27 of 27 apps say they ship.

Is a no-fee auction really free for the seller?

Fanatics Collect charges the seller nothing on a graded card, but adds 20% to the winning bid. If the winner pays $500 all in, the bid is $416.67 and you are paid $433.33 with the bonus.

What is the fastest way to turn a pull into money?

The sell-back: it needs no buyer and no parcel. It also has a clock, as short as 15 minutes on the apps that publish one. Vault or ship has every app's clock.

Which route leaves the most for a cheap card?

At $50, fixed costs decide it: postage and per-order fees take a large share on every route that needs a parcel. Run your own card through the selling fee comparer.

Sources104

  1. Fanatics Collect: Selling on Fanatics Collect support.fanaticscollect.com
  2. Fanatics Collect: How Fanatics Collect works (commission chart) support.fanaticscollect.com
  3. Fanatics Collect: current timeframes for shipping, curation and seller payouts support.fanaticscollect.com
  4. Fanatics Collect: FanCash payouts support.fanaticscollect.com
  5. Fanatics Collect: Weekly Auction support.fanaticscollect.com
  6. PSA: eBay consignment rates (archive copy of 31 July 2026) web.archive.org
  7. PSA: PSA Vault (fees in the FAQ) (archive copy of 27 August 2026) web.archive.org
  8. eBay: seller fees ebay.com
  9. Whatnot: seller fees help.whatnot.com
  10. Whatnot: reduced commission on high-value orders help.whatnot.com
  11. Arena Club: payout form arenaclubsupport.zendesk.com
  12. Arena Club: buyback rate, time limit info.arenaclub.com
  13. Arena Club: selling fee arenaclubsupport.zendesk.com
  14. Arena Club: withdrawals, withdrawal minimum arenaclubsupport.zendesk.com
  15. Arena Club: shipping arenaclubsupport.zendesk.com
  16. Arena Club: shipping fee arenaclubsupport.zendesk.com
  17. Arena Club: shipping time arenaclubsupport.zendesk.com
  18. Lastpack: payout form, buyback rate, shipping support.lastpack.com
  19. Lastpack: time limit, withdrawals support.lastpack.com
  20. Lastpack: withdrawal minimum support.lastpack.com
  21. Lastpack: shipping fee, shipping time support.lastpack.com
  22. Phygitals: payout form, buyback rate, time limit docs.phygitals.com
  23. Phygitals: withdrawals docs.phygitals.com
  24. Phygitals: shipping, shipping time docs.phygitals.com
  25. Phygitals: shipping fee docs.phygitals.com
  26. Repackz: payout form, buyback rate, selling fee, time limit collectibles.helpscoutdocs.com
  27. Repackz: withdrawals, withdrawal minimum collectibles.helpscoutdocs.com
  28. Repackz: shipping collectibles.helpscoutdocs.com
  29. Repackz: shipping fee collectibles.helpscoutdocs.com
  30. Tilt Rips: payout form, buyback rate, selling fee, withdrawals, shipping, shipping time tiltrips.com
  31. Courtyard: payout form docs.courtyard.io
  32. Courtyard: time limit help.courtyard.io
  33. Courtyard: withdrawals help.courtyard.io
  34. Courtyard: shipping, shipping time docs.courtyard.io
  35. Courtyard: shipping fee help.courtyard.io
  36. Ripit: payout form support.ripit.co
  37. Ripit: time limit support.ripit.co
  38. Ripit: withdrawals support.ripit.co
  39. Ripit: shipping, shipping fee, shipping time support.ripit.co
  40. Packz: payout form, time limit, withdrawals, shipping, shipping time packz.io
  41. RipRip.io: payout form, buyback rate, time limit, withdrawals riprip.io
  42. RipRip.io: shipping riprip.io
  43. rip.fun: payout form docs.rip.fun
  44. rip.fun: buyback rate rip.fun
  45. rip.fun: time limit docs.rip.fun
  46. rip.fun: shipping, shipping fee, shipping time docs.rip.fun
  47. Collector Crypt: payout form, time limit, withdrawals docs.collectorcrypt.com
  48. Collector Crypt: buyback rate, selling fee docs.collectorcrypt.com
  49. Collector Crypt: shipping docs.collectorcrypt.com
  50. Collector Crypt: shipping fee collectorcrypt.com
  51. MNSTR: payout form mnstr.xyz
  52. MNSTR: buyback rate mnstr.xyz
  53. MNSTR: shipping, shipping fee mnstr.xyz
  54. Rips by Triumph: payout form, withdrawal minimum intercom.help
  55. Rips by Triumph: buyback rate docs.triumpharcade.com
  56. Rips by Triumph: time limit, withdrawals, shipping, shipping time docs.triumpharcade.com
  57. Slabz: payout form, buyback rate, time limit, withdrawals, shipping, shipping fee slabz.com
  58. BOXED.GG: payout form helpdesk.boxed.gg
  59. BOXED.GG: buyback rate helpdesk.boxed.gg
  60. BOXED.GG: withdrawals helpdesk.boxed.gg
  61. BOXED.GG: shipping, shipping fee, shipping time boxed.gg
  62. Stadium Vault: payout form, time limit, withdrawals, shipping time stadium-vault.gitbook.io
  63. Stadium Vault: buyback rate, selling fee, shipping stadium-vault.gitbook.io
  64. Rip Rush: payout form, time limit, withdrawals, withdrawal minimum, shipping, shipping time riprush.net
  65. Rip Rush: buyback rate riprush.net
  66. Underdog Rips: payout form apps.apple.com
  67. Underdog Rips: buyback rate help.underdogsports.com
  68. Underdog Rips: time limit, shipping underdogfantasy.pactsafe.io
  69. Underdog Rips: withdrawals legal.underdogsports.com
  70. Underdog Rips: shipping fee, shipping time help.underdogsports.com
  71. Fanatics Instant Rips: payout form support.fanaticscollect.com
  72. Fanatics Instant Rips: buyback rate support.fanaticscollect.com
  73. Fanatics Instant Rips: selling fee about.fanatics.live
  74. Fanatics Instant Rips: time limit fanatics.live
  75. Fanatics Instant Rips: shipping, shipping time support.fanaticscollect.com
  76. Fanatics Instant Rips: shipping fee support.fanaticscollect.com
  77. ClutchPacks: payout form, withdrawals, shipping clutchpacks.io
  78. ClutchPacks: buyback rate clutchpacks.io
  79. Beezie: payout form, selling fee docs.beezie.com
  80. Beezie: buyback rate beezie.com
  81. Beezie: time limit docs.beezie.com
  82. Beezie: withdrawals docs.beezie.com
  83. Beezie: shipping docs.beezie.com
  84. Beezie: shipping fee docs.beezie.com
  85. DOPA: payout form, withdrawals dopa-global.com
  86. DOPA: buyback rate dopa-global.com
  87. DOPA: time limit support.dopa-global.com
  88. DOPA: shipping support.dopa-global.com
  89. DOPA: shipping fee support.dopa-global.com
  90. DOPA: shipping time support.dopa-global.com
  91. Packs.com: payout form, buyback rate, withdrawals packs.com
  92. Packs.com: selling fee help.packs.com
  93. Packs.com: time limit, shipping packs.com
  94. Packs.com: shipping fee, shipping time help.packs.com
  95. GameStop Power Packs: payout form, time limit powerpacks.gamestop.com
  96. GameStop Power Packs: selling fee powerpacks.gamestop.com
  97. GameStop Power Packs: withdrawals, shipping gamestop.com
  98. Gemint: payout form, withdrawals, shipping help.gemint.io
  99. Gemint: buyback rate, selling fee gemint.io
  100. Crown Cards: payout form, selling fee, time limit, withdrawals, shipping, shipping time crowncards.io
  101. Crown Cards: buyback rate crowncards.io
  102. ripz.gg: payout form, shipping, shipping fee ripz.gg
  103. ripz.gg: buyback rate, shipping time ripz.gg
  104. ripz.gg: withdrawals ripz.gg
Alexander Korsager

Alexander Korsager

Every figure was read on public pages between 6 October 2026 and 7 October 2026. Nothing here has been tested with money yet. Fanatics Collect's help pages were read on 7 October 2026; PSA's consignment rates in an archive copy of 31 July 2026. Nothing has been sold, shipped or consigned. We earn nothing from any marketplace or consigner named here. How apps are scored is on the rating method page.